BSS
  04 Jan 2022, 09:02

Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes guilty in fraud trial

SAN FRANCISCO, Jan 4, 2022 (BSS/AFP) - Fallen US biotech star Elizabeth
Holmes was convicted on Monday of defrauding investors in her blood-testing
startup Theranos, in a high-profile case seen as an indictment of Silicon
Valley culture.

   Holmes is a rare example of a tech exec being brought to book over a
company flaming out, in a sector littered with the carcasses of money-losing
companies that once promised untold riches.

   Her case shone a spotlight on the blurred line between the hustle that
characterizes the industry and outright criminal dishonesty.

   Jurors took seven days of deliberations to reach their verdict, finding
her guilty of four counts of tricking investors into pouring money into what
she claimed was a revolutionary testing system.

   But the panel -- who had listened to weeks of sometimes complex evidence -
- also acquitted her on four charges and could not reach a verdict on three
others.

   The 37-year-old now faces the possibility of 20 years behind bars for each
conviction. She remains at liberty ahead of another hearing on the terms of
her bail next week. No date was set for sentencing.

   She made no comment as she left the court when asked if she intended to
appeal.

   Holmes had vowed to revolutionize health diagnostics with self-service
machines that could run an array of tests on just a few drops of blood, a
vision that drew high-profile backers and made her a billionaire by the age
of 30. She was hailed as the next tech visionary on magazine covers and
collected mountains of investors' cash, but it all collapsed after Wall
Street Journal reporting revealed the machines did not work as promised.

   Prosecutors spent 11 weeks presenting over two dozen witnesses, as they
painstakingly laid out their argument that Holmes knew her technology fell
short, and deliberately misled investors and patients.

   She personally put the logos of pharma giants Pfizer and Schering-Plough
onto Theranos reports hailing the company's blood-testing technology, which
were then shared with investors.

   That was done without the firms' permissions, and was a key piece of the
prosecution's argument that she purposely tried to inflate Theranos's
credibility in order to win backers.

   - 'Fake it till you make it' -

   Though big-name Theranos investors like Rupert Murdoch and Henry Kissinger
were on the witness list, the most prominent backer to take the stand was ex-
Pentagon chief Jim Mattis.

   The defense called only one significant witness, Holmes herself, as it
argued the fallen entrepreneur had genuinely believed in Theranos's vision,
invested herself heavily in its success and had simply failed.

   Holmes also sought to shift some of the blame to Ramesh "Sunny" Balwani, a
boyfriend nearly two decades her senior whom she had brought in to help run
her company.

   She fought back tears as she told jurors that Balwani denigrated her and
forced himself on her sexually when angry -- accusations that he has strongly
denied.

   He is due to stand trial separately for his role in the company's
operations and has pleaded not guilty.

   Beyond the reams of company documents, highly detailed technical questions
and Holmes's at-times emotional testimony, there loomed the question of
Silicon Valley's very nature.

   One of the startup world's most repeated cliches is "fake it till you make
it", where ambitious entrepreneurs with an idea that almost works convince
people to invest massive sums of money in the hope that one day it will.

   It is exceedingly rare for founders of failed Silicon Valley companies --
of which there are many -- to face fraud prosecution over unrealized promises
and unreturned investments.

   Some tech world figures, like former Reddit chief Ellen Pao, said sexism
may have been a factor in the prosecution, but others argued Holmes had gone
too far in trying to prop up her steadily dissolving vision.

   After the 2015 Wall Street Journal reporting that questioned whether
Theranos's machines worked as promised -- and ultimately brought down the
company -- Holmes went on the offensive in the media.

   "First they think you're crazy, then they fight you, then all of the
sudden you change the world," said in a TV interview.